2011 – Austin Peay, Boise State, UCF, Creighton, Davidson, Duquesne, Evansville, Hofstra, James Madison,
Miami (Ohio), Montana, Oregon, Rhode Island, Saint Bonaventure, San Jose State, Weber State

2010 – Akron, Boston University, Charleston, Colorado State, Duquesne, Eastern Kentucky, George Washington,
Green Bay, Hofstra, Indiana State, IUPUI, Morehead State, Oregon State, Princeton, Saint Louis,
Virginia Commonwealth

2009 – Boise State, Buffalo, Charleston, Green Bay, Houston, Nevada, Houston, Northeastern, Oregon State, Richmond, St. John's, Stanford, Troy, UTEP, Vermont, Wichita State, Wyoming

2008 – Bradley, Brown, Cincinnati, Houston, Miami (Ohio), Nevada, Ohio, Old Dominion, Richmond, Rider, Tulsa, Utah, UTEP, Valparaiso, Virginia, Washington

champions in bold italic
runner-up in championship series in bold